When someone creates a will, trust, or other estate planning document in the State of Florida, the document should reflect that person’s own intent rather than the improper influence of another person. Unfortunately, there are times when a vulnerable individual is pressured or manipulated into making decisions that do not represent their actual intent.
Known as undue influence, this issue can arise in disputes involving wills, trusts, lifetime transfers, beneficiary designations, and other estate-planning decisions. When undue influence affects the creation, amendment, execution, or revocation of a will or trust, all or part of the affected document may be subject to challenge. These cases are highly fact-specific, often complex, and may require experienced probate or trust litigation counsel.
An undue influence lawyer can help beneficiaries, heirs, fiduciaries, and other interested parties investigate suspicious estate-planning changes, preserve and gather relevant evidence, and pursue or defend a legal challenge involving alleged undue influence.
Undue Influence Matters We Handle
Undue influence can affect more than a traditional will. Di Pietro Partners represents clients in disputes involving suspicious changes to wills, trusts, property ownership, beneficiary arrangements, and other estate-planning decisions.
These matters may include:
- Will contests involving allegations that a beneficiary, family member, caregiver, or other person improperly influenced the testator;
- Challenges to trusts that were created, amended, restated, or revoked under alleged undue influence;
- Disputes involving deeds or other lifetime transfers of real estate or property;
- Challenges involving beneficiary designations or other transfers made outside the probate estate;
- Cases involving alleged undue influence together with lack of capacity, fraud, fiduciary misconduct, or financial exploitation; and
- Defense of beneficiaries, trustees, fiduciaries, or other parties accused of improperly influencing an estate-planning decision.
Because the appropriate legal claim and court proceeding can depend on the type of document or transfer involved, an experienced probate and trust litigation attorney can evaluate the circumstances and determine what legal options may be available.
When Should You Contact an Undue Influence Lawyer?
You may want to speak with an undue influence lawyer when circumstances surrounding a will, trust, or transfer raise questions about whether the person acted freely and independently.
Potential reasons to seek legal advice include:
- A will or trust was substantially changed shortly before a person’s death;
- A longtime beneficiary was unexpectedly removed or received a significantly smaller inheritance;
- A caregiver, family member, spouse, or other person became heavily involved in the individual’s financial or estate-planning decisions;
- The individual was isolated from relatives, friends, or longtime advisors;
- The person was experiencing dementia, memory problems, serious illness, or other conditions that may have increased vulnerability to pressure;
- A new beneficiary received a substantial benefit after arranging meetings with attorneys or participating in the preparation of estate-planning documents;
- Unexpected deeds, gifts, beneficiary changes, account transfers, or other transactions occurred near the same time as changes to the estate plan; or
- You have been accused of exerting undue influence and need to defend the validity of a will, trust, or transfer.
These circumstances do not necessarily prove undue influence. However, they may justify a closer review of the estate-planning documents, surrounding evidence, and applicable filing deadlines.
Why Choose Di Pietro Partners for an Undue Influence Case?
Undue influence disputes often involve more than interpreting an estate-planning document. They can require careful investigation, witness testimony, medical and financial evidence, discovery, and contested court proceedings. Di Pietro Partners is a litigation-focused firm with substantial courtroom experience handling complex probate, estate, and trust disputes throughout Florida.
Clients choose Di Pietro Partners for undue influence and related probate litigation because:
- Probate and trust litigation is a core focus of the firm. Our attorneys handle contested wills, trust disputes, inheritance disputes, fiduciary claims, lack-of-capacity matters, and other complex estate litigation.
- We understand these disputes from multiple perspectives. The firm represents beneficiaries, heirs, trustees, personal representatives, fiduciaries, and other interested parties in probate and trust matters.
- Our attorneys are prepared for litigation. Undue influence cases may require extensive discovery, witness examinations, review of medical and financial records, evidentiary hearings, and trial. Di Pietro Partners brings substantial courtroom experience to these disputes.
- Clients work directly with the attorneys handling their cases. This allows the legal strategy to reflect the specific family relationships, financial issues, documents, and evidence involved in the dispute.
- We represent clients throughout Florida. Di Pietro Partners is based in Fort Lauderdale and handles probate and trust litigation matters statewide.
Client feedback involving contested probate and trust matters frequently highlights the firm’s responsiveness, personal attention, legal guidance, and ability to help clients navigate difficult and emotionally charged disputes.
Proving Undue Influence in Florida
Challenging a will or trust based on undue influence requires the appropriate court proceeding for the type of estate-planning document involved. A will contest is generally raised through the Florida probate process, while a challenge involving the validity of a trust may proceed as a separate civil action. Strict filing and objection deadlines can apply, so it is important to evaluate a potential claim promptly. A probate or trust litigation attorney will begin by reviewing the estate planning documents, gathering background information about the circumstances under which they were signed, and identifying any suspicious changes or relationships that could point to undue influence.
The discovery phase is a critical part of the process. Because undue influence rarely happens in front of witnesses, evidence is often circumstantial and pieced together from various sources. Evidence may include medical records that show the vulnerability of the testator or settlor, financial records indicating sudden transfers, estate planning files, and testimony from individuals who observed the relationship between the alleged influencer and the person whose estate plan is being challenged. In some cases, the evidence may give rise to a rebuttable presumption of undue influence. In a Florida will contest, when that presumption applies, it shifts the burden of proof under Florida law.
If the case proceeds to trial, the court will evaluate the relevant evidence and determine whether the will, trust, or estate-planning decision was the product of undue influence. Under Florida Statutes § 732.5165, a will or portion of a will procured by undue influence is void. Florida law similarly provides under Florida Statutes § 736.0406 that a trust, or an amendment, restatement, or revocation of a trust, is void to the extent it was procured by undue influence. What happens to the affected property afterward depends on the circumstances and the remaining valid estate-planning documents. Assets may ultimately pass under other valid provisions, a prior valid estate-planning instrument, or Florida intestacy law, depending on the case. Some cases may be resolved through negotiation or settlement before reaching trial, which can save time and preserve estate value.
Speak With an Undue Influence Attorney
Undue influence disputes can involve significant inheritances, complicated family relationships, and estate-planning changes that may be difficult to investigate after a loved one has died. Strict filing and objection deadlines can also apply, making it important to evaluate a potential claim promptly.
Di Pietro Partners represents beneficiaries, heirs, trustees, personal representatives, fiduciaries, and other interested parties in contested probate and trust matters throughout Florida. Based in Fort Lauderdale, our attorneys handle undue influence claims involving wills, trusts, beneficiary changes, lifetime transfers, and other disputed estate-planning decisions statewide.
Whether you believe a loved one was improperly influenced or you are defending against an allegation of undue influence, contact Di Pietro Partners for a free and confidential consultation with a Florida undue influence attorney.

