Well-designed estate plans designate rights and responsibilities of trustees and beneficiaries. However, disagreements regarding the administration or distribution of a trust may require legal advice. If you are a trustee or beneficiary experiencing difficulties with the administration of a trust, contact an experienced estate litigation attorney. An attorney may be able to help resolve the dispute before litigation becomes necessary. If court intervention is required, the attorney can represent your interests throughout the trust litigation process.
Key Takeaways
- Trustees owe fiduciary duties to beneficiaries. Florida trustees must administer the trust in good faith, follow its terms, manage trust property prudently, and avoid improper conflicts of interest or self-dealing.
- Beneficiaries have important rights. Depending on the circumstances, qualified beneficiaries may be entitled to information about the trust, accountings, required distributions, and other information concerning trust administration.
- Not every delay or unfavorable decision is trustee misconduct. A trustee may have legitimate reasons for delaying a distribution, and many trusts give trustees significant discretion. However, that discretion is not unlimited and must be exercised consistently with the trust and Florida law.
- Beneficiaries have legal options when a trustee fails to perform required duties. A court may order an accounting, compel the trustee to act, stop a breach of trust, restore trust property, reduce compensation, or impose other appropriate remedies.
- Serious trustee misconduct can lead to personal liability or removal. When warranted by the circumstances, a trustee may be required to compensate the trust for losses or profits resulting from a breach and may also be suspended or removed by the court.
Roles of Trustee and Beneficiary
Trustees and beneficiaries have different rights and responsibilities under a trust. Trustees owe fiduciary duties when administering trust property, while beneficiaries have rights established by the trust document and the Florida Trust Code.
- Trustee – A trustee is an individual or entity appointed to administer and manage trust property. Under Florida law, a trustee must administer the trust in good faith and in accordance with its terms, purposes, and the interests of the beneficiaries. Trustees also have duties of loyalty and prudent administration and, when a trust has multiple beneficiaries, must give appropriate consideration to their respective interests.
- Beneficiary – A trust may have one or multiple beneficiaries, including family members, other individuals, or organizations. A beneficiary’s rights depend on the terms of the trust and applicable Florida law. Those rights may include receiving distributions provided by the trust and, for qualified beneficiaries, receiving certain information and accountings concerning the trust’s administration.
Common Disputes between Trustees and Beneficiaries
Disagreements regarding settling a trust arise for a variety of reasons. Common disputes include:
- Mismanagement of trust assets – A trust may include stocks, real estate, cash, business interests, and other property. Florida law requires trustees to administer trust assets prudently and exercise reasonable care, skill, and caution. A beneficiary may raise concerns when a trustee makes imprudent investments, fails to protect trust property, incurs unreasonable expenses, or otherwise mismanages trust assets. Depending on the circumstances, a beneficiary may seek court intervention to prevent or remedy a breach of trust.
- Breach of fiduciary duty – A trustee must administer the trust in accordance with its terms and fiduciary duties. When a trust has multiple beneficiaries, Florida law generally requires the trustee to act impartially and give appropriate consideration to each beneficiary’s respective interests. Favoring one beneficiary contrary to the trust terms or without a proper basis may lead to a breach of fiduciary duty claim.
- Undue influence or coercion – A beneficiary may challenge the creation or amendment of a trust if there is evidence that another person improperly influenced or coerced the settlor into making changes they would not otherwise have made. Under Florida law, a trust or portion of a trust procured through undue influence or duress may be void. Lack of mental capacity is a separate potential basis for challenging the validity of a trust.
- Failure to distribute assets – Disputes may arise when a beneficiary believes the trustee is improperly delaying or withholding a distribution required by the trust. Not every delay is improper. A trustee may need time to administer trust property, resolve claims, address expenses or tax issues, and comply with the terms of the trust. When a trust terminates, Florida law generally requires the trustee to proceed expeditiously with distribution while permitting the trustee to retain a reasonable reserve for debts, expenses, and taxes.
- Accounting disputes – Florida law gives qualified beneficiaries important rights to information about a trust and its administration. Depending on the circumstances, a trustee may be required to provide trust accountings, a copy of the trust instrument upon reasonable request, and relevant information concerning the trust’s assets, liabilities, and administration. A trustee’s failure to provide information or accountings required by law may lead to a trust dispute or court action.
- Self-Dealing and Conflicts of Interest – A trustee may also be a beneficiary of the trust, but the trustee’s fiduciary duties still apply. Disputes can arise when a trustee uses trust property, makes transactions, or exercises authority in a way that improperly benefits themselves or another related party at the expense of other beneficiaries. Florida law generally requires trustees to administer the trust solely in the interests of the beneficiaries and places restrictions on transactions affected by conflicts between the trustee’s fiduciary and personal interests.
What Can a Beneficiary Do When a Trustee Is Not Cooperating?
A beneficiary may become concerned when a trustee refuses to make distributions, stops communicating, or will not provide information about the trust. Whether the trustee is acting improperly depends on the terms of the trust, the status of the administration, and the reason for the trustee’s actions.
If the Trustee Is Withholding a Distribution – A trustee cannot simply ignore a distribution required by the trust. However, not every delay is improper. The trustee may need time to identify and value assets, resolve claims, address expenses or tax issues, or retain a reasonable reserve before completing distributions.
If a beneficiary believes a required distribution is being improperly delayed or withheld, the first step is often to review the trust document and determine what the trustee is actually required to distribute and when.
If the Trustee Will Not Provide Information – Florida law gives qualified beneficiaries important rights to information concerning the trust and its administration. Depending on the circumstances, this may include trust accountings, a copy of the trust instrument, and information about trust assets, liabilities, and administration.
A beneficiary who is not receiving required information may make a written request and, if necessary, seek a court order requiring the trustee to provide an accounting or other information.
Legal Options for Beneficiaries – When a trustee fails to perform required duties, a beneficiary may have several options depending on the circumstances. A Florida court may be asked to compel the trustee to perform a duty, provide an accounting, stop an ongoing breach of trust, restore improperly lost or transferred trust property, reduce trustee compensation, or suspend or remove the trustee.
Because the appropriate response depends heavily on the trust document and the trustee’s conduct, beneficiaries should document their requests and concerns and have the trust reviewed before taking legal action.
What Should a Beneficiary Document?
If concerns arise about a trustee’s conduct, beneficiaries should begin preserving relevant records early. Depending on the dispute, useful documentation may include:
- The trust document and any amendments
- Trust accountings and financial statements
- Records of distributions received or expected
- Written requests for information or distributions
- Emails, letters, and other communications with the trustee
- Bank, investment, or property records relating to trust assets
- Documents showing expenses, transfers, or transactions that may be disputed
Keeping a clear record of requests, responses, and financial activity can help an attorney evaluate whether the trustee is complying with the trust and whether further action may be appropriate.
How Much Discretion Does a Trustee Have?
The trust document is the starting point for determining how much discretion a trustee has. Some trusts give trustees substantial authority over distributions, investments, property management, and other administrative decisions.
However, broad discretion does not give a trustee unlimited authority. Under Florida law, even discretionary powers described as “absolute,” “sole,” or “uncontrolled” must generally be exercised in good faith and in accordance with the terms and purposes of the trust and the interests of the beneficiaries.
At the same time, a beneficiary’s disagreement with a trustee’s decision does not necessarily mean the trustee has breached a duty. Whether a trustee has improperly exercised discretion depends on the trust language, the reason for the decision, and the surrounding circumstances.
Protections under Florida Law
Florida law provides important rights and protections for both beneficiaries and trustees. The Florida Trust Code (Chapter 736, Florida Statutes) generally governs the creation, administration, modification, and termination of Florida trusts within its scope. It also establishes trustee duties, beneficiary rights, and procedures for resolving trust disputes.
Legal Remedies
Trustee and beneficiary disputes may be complex. Contact an attorney that specializes in trust litigation if you are having issues regarding a trust. Remember, just because you don’t like the terms of a trust is not a legal reason to fight it. There must be a solid claim of wrongdoing to dispute a trust. Some examples of when you may seek legal help include:
- Breach of fiduciary duty
- Mismanagement of trust assets
- Lack of transparency
- Excessive trustee compensation
- Undue influence
If a breach of trust is established, Florida courts may order a range of remedies depending on the circumstances. These can include compelling the trustee to perform required duties, ordering an accounting, restoring improperly lost or transferred property, suspending or removing the trustee, or reducing or denying trustee compensation.
So, beneficiaries unhappy with a trust’s execution should contact a trust litigation attorney. Remember, you must have EVIDENCE to contest a trust. Additionally, a Florida trustee may want to hire an experienced trust lawyer. This protects the trust and the trustee. In conclusion, some estates are settled without any problems. Yet, when there are conflicts, seek legal advice.
Can a Trustee Be Personally Liable?
Yes. A trustee who breaches a fiduciary duty can potentially face personal financial liability. Depending on the circumstances, a court may require the trustee to restore losses to the trust, return profits obtained through the breach, or otherwise compensate for harm caused by improper administration.
However, a trustee is not personally liable simply because trust property loses value or an investment fails. Florida law generally requires an actual breach of trust before liability for those losses can be imposed.
When Can a Trustee Be Removed in Florida?
Beneficiaries do not have the automatic right to remove a trustee simply because they disagree with the trustee’s decisions or do not get along with the person serving in that role. A beneficiary, settlor, or cotrustee may ask a Florida court to remove a trustee when the circumstances meet the requirements of Florida law.
A court may remove a trustee when:
- The trustee has committed a serious breach of trust
- A lack of cooperation among cotrustees substantially interferes with administration of the trust
- The trustee is unfit, unwilling, or persistently fails to administer the trust effectively and removal is in the beneficiaries’ best interests
- Certain circumstances have substantially changed, or all qualified beneficiaries request removal, and the additional requirements under Florida law are satisfied
Examples of conduct that may lead to a removal dispute can include repeated failures to provide required accountings, improper handling of trust property, serious conflicts of interest, failure to follow the trust, or persistent problems administering required distributions.
Trustee removal is a court proceeding, and the trustee has an opportunity to respond to the allegations and defend their conduct. While a removal case is pending, the court may also take other steps to protect the trust or beneficiaries, including suspending the trustee or appointing a special fiduciary when appropriate.
Because removal is a significant remedy, the trust document, financial records, accountings, communications, and the trustee’s conduct should be carefully evaluated before seeking removal.
